Skip to content

Wood Burning Fireplace Inserts

Best Wood Stove Insert for Your Home

If your old fireplace looks great but doesn’t heat the room like it should, it might be time for a change. A wood stove insert gives you the beauty of a real fire with the high-efficiency warmth today’s homes need.

These units slide directly into your existing firebox, sealing off drafts and delivering serious heat output, all while using less wood. Whether you're updating a dated hearth or planning a full remodel, our collection of Wood Burning Fireplace Inserts offers curated options that balance performance, style, and long-term value.

We carry only the best fireplace inserts for sale, including models with blowers, EPA certification, and sizes that match real-world homes.

Filters

Types of Wood Burning Fireplace Inserts To Consider

Explore a variety of wood burning fireplace inserts to find the perfect fit for your home.

  • Catalytic Inserts: Equipped with a catalyst for cleaner and more efficient burns, these are ideal for frequent use and high-efficiency heating.

  • Non-Catalytic Inserts: Simpler to maintain, these models are user-friendly and offer reliable heating without the need for a catalyst.

Top Picks: Best Wood Stove Inserts for Your Home

Each of these top-rated inserts brings something different to the table, whether you need serious heat or a timeless look.

Best Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Drolet Escape 1800-I Wood Insert

Drolet Escape 1800-I Wood Insert

High-output heat for up to 2,100 sq ft. Clean lines, durable steel build, and perfect for big, open rooms.

Best Traditional Style Wood Fireplace Insert

Timberwolf Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Timberwolf Wood Burning Fireplace Insert

Classic design with solid efficiency. A great fit for traditional homes and everyday use.

Best Wood Fireplace Inserts with Blower

Drolet Escape 1500-I Wood Insert With Faceplate

Drolet Escape 1500-I Wood Insert With Faceplate

Compact, clean design with a built-in blower. Ideal for mid-size rooms that need extra warmth.

How to Choose the Right Wood Stove Insert for Your Fireplace

Finding the right wood stove insert for your fireplace comes down to matching your space, heating needs, and lifestyle. Here's what to look for:

Size & BTU Output

The right wood burning fireplace insert depends on your square footage and how much heat you actually need. Unlike general estimates, we base our guidance on actual product specs:

  • Up to 1,800 sq ft → 55,000–65,000 BTUs

  • Up to 2,100 sq ft → 65,000–75,000 BTUs

  • Up to 2,700+ sq ft → 85,000–110,000+ BTUs

Heating Efficiency

Choose EPA-certified inserts for eco-friendly performance, with 70%+ efficiency ratings to maximize heat output and minimize wood waste. Features like insulated fireboxes and secondary combustion systems reduce emissions and save on fuel costs.

Key Features to Consider

  • Blower Included: Boosts airflow to heat your space faster.

  • Ash Pan: Easier cleanup between burns.

  • Ceramic Glass Doors: Better heat retention and safety.

  • Thermostatic Controls: For precision and comfort.

Installation & Maintenance

Professional installation ensures safety and compliance. Regularly clean the firebox and chimney to prevent creosote buildup, and use seasoned hardwood to maintain peak performance. Catalytic models require occasional combustor replacement for optimal efficiency.

Featured Wood Stove Brands You Can Trust

We only stock brands we know deliver because a wood burning fireplace insert is an investment in long-term comfort.

  • Drolet Fireplace – Built in Canada, Drolet inserts are known for high heat output, rugged steel construction, and reliable performance in colder climates.

  • Timberwolf Fireplace – Blending traditional aesthetics with solid efficiency, Timberwolf models are ideal for homeowners who want classic looks with modern heating power.

Whether you need serious square footage coverage or a timeless design, these brands have you covered.

Why Buy Your Wood Fireplace Insert from Fire Pit Surplus?

At Fire Pit Surplus, we don't just sell wood fire stoves; we help you choose the right one for your space, style, and heating needs. Whether you're replacing an old unit or upgrading to something more efficient, our expert team is here to guide you every step of the way.

  • Fast, free shipping on all inserts

  • Low-price guarantee for added peace of mind

  • Financing options available at checkout

  • Real-person support from selection to installation

Frequently Asked Questions: Wood Stove Insert

Do wood burning fireplace inserts require a chimney?

Yes, a chimney is required. Most wood burning fireplace inserts include or require a stainless-steel liner to ensure safe, efficient venting and meet building codes for modern installations.

What's the difference between a catalytic and non-catalytic wood insert?

Catalytic wood inserts use a combustor to boost efficiency and reduce emissions. Non-catalytic models are simpler, easier to maintain, and better for moderate use or first-time buyers.

How much space can a wood burning insert heat?

Depending on the BTU output, a wood stove insert for fireplace setups can heat 1,500 to over 3,000 sq ft. Larger models like the Drolet 1800-I are ideal for open-concept or multi-room heating.

Are wood burning inserts eco-friendly?

Yes. All modern wood burning fireplace inserts sold at Fire Pit Surplus meet EPA standards, offering cleaner burns, reduced emissions, and more efficient wood use compared to open fireplaces.

Are wood stove inserts worth it?

Absolutely. A wood burning stove insert improves heat retention, cuts down on wood use, and gives your fireplace a modern, high-efficiency upgrade, saving money and energy long-term.

Can I put a wood stove insert in my fireplace?

Most standard masonry fireplaces can accommodate a wood stove insert, but accurate measurements and a proper chimney liner are essential. We recommend professional installation for safety.

What is the difference between a wood stove and a wood stove insert?

A wood stove is freestanding and heats from any location. A wood stove insert fits into an existing fireplace and is typically more efficient at radiating heat within a defined space.

Final Word: Discover Best Wood Fireplace Inserts For Sale

A Wood Stove Inserts adds serious warmth, saves on energy, and brings your old hearth back to life. Whether you're upgrading for efficiency, style, or both, our handpicked selection of wood fireplace inserts for sale is ready to deliver.

Explore the collection, compare features, and find the insert that fits your space, your style, and your plans for cozy nights in.